Insanimation's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[A Grand Ship]

Kinda funny..

Art/Animation: 6/10
I really liked that paper texture. It gave it that indie feel that many animations on here have.
The animation itself was pretty good...Decent FBF and stuff..Nothing amazing, but it was good enough..
The art sorta let you down though..A lot of it was rough around the edges. I think it would have been better if you had added black outlines to everything.

Plot/Concept: 5/10
Not a bad little joke, but slightly clichéd and predictable. Also, it was nice to have the subtitles, but if you're gonna do them, at least spell everything right..Generally, it was alright, but you wrote Lincon Park, whereas it should be Linkin Park, who are awesome by the way :D

Audio/Music: 8/10
The sound quality was quite good, and the voices were great, lots of emotion in it and stuff...The accents weren't very piratey though, and since it was "Talk Like a Pirate Day", they probably should have been...

Overall: 6/10
Not terrible, but not good enough to be a good story, or have excellent animation.

[Review Request Club]

[Chibi Theatre 1]

Didn't really work..

Art/Animation: 3/10
There wasn't anything here that was any good. The characters were pretty simple and boring. The fire effect wasn't bad, but it didn't loop properly. Sometimes, the subtitles went by too quickly to read fully.

Plot/Concept: 3/10
I didn't find it funny, to be honest..The build up was too slow and boring, and the punchline just wasn't funny enough to even it out.

Sound/Music: 4/10
The music was alright, but didn't add much to the flash..When the third guy came in, the music stopped for a bit too long before the second track came on.
Some voice actors would have been nice too.

Overall: 3/10
It wasn't funny, nor well animated. Nothing appealed to me..

[Review Request Club]

PikaRobo responds:

Well even though I do understand what you mean and I will try to listen to most of your advice keep in mind this IS the first Flash I ever made, so it is no surprise why it is so low in quality. Hopefully the next one improved a little, as it is a LITTLE bit closer to what I want it to be. And maybe future episodes will meet standards.

[Skeleton's Revenge]

Eeeeh..

Art/Animation: 2/10
Sprites are renowned for being one of the easiest methods of animating. However, you didn't even do them very well. The running sequences were not synced and there was no weight to it, often when they were standing around, they were jerking about the screen, and it just looked poor. The timing was also pretty bad. Everything went too slowly for my liking.

Plot/Concept: 5/10
It was an interesting enough story...Not much plot or subplot or anything to make a properly decent flash, but enough to provide a bit of humour and keep me interested..

Audio/Music: 5/10
A few more sound effects, and possibly a bit of voice would be nice..The music was quite good though, building up well.

Overall: 4/10
You have the bare bones of a good movie, but a lot of work needs to be put into the animation side of it. Good luck.

[Review Request Club]

[Frodozers Vs. Clock Day]

Well, it was Clock Day..

Art/Animation: 3/10
Well, sprites..what can I say? Considering there is so little going on, wouldn't it have been nice to just to do a bit of proper vector animation for once? I gotta say though, as sprites go, they were pretty good.

Plot/Concept: 0/10
Well, there wasn't really one. Also, considering that this was a Clock Day flash, a single clock woulda been nice. Obviously it was just a 2 second loop, so thee really isn't much to judge here.

Audio/Music: 7/10
Well, it's Sonofkirk, so it's obviously awesome, but not really enough to redeem this flash.

Overall: 3/10
I realise that it was a Clock Day flash, and it's supposed to be spam, but that doesn't take away from the fact that it isn't too good..

[Review Request Club]

Fro responds:

Lol at how people keep saying it's a loop even though each one was animated at different frame rates and it was actually about 2,000 to 3,000 frames with an ending.

[Sad Link]

Pretty good

Art/Animation: 7/10
The art was quite nice, but a bit sloppy..The shading was really good though..There wasn't much animation, simply tweens..The animation of Mario's head moving back was a bit jumpy. Try to add in more frames.

Plot/Concept: 4/10
It was kinda funny, but not laugh-out-loud..There wasn't really a plot either, and it was really short.

Music/Audio: 7/10
The music wasn't too bad. It didn't fit the flash perfectly, but it was sufficient. There are loads of sad songs on NG, so you could have found a better one.

Overall: 6/10
Not bad, but nothing fantastic.

[Review Request Club]

J0hnnyR0tt3n responds:

thanks.

[Don't Fuck With Tray]

Much too short.

Art/Animation: 7/10
The lip-syncing was quite good, and the morph wasn't good, except the clothes seemed to completely disappear after a bit.

Plot/Concept: 1/10
Well, it was too short to actually take anything in. There was no plot, no humour, nothing really..

Audio/Music: 5/10
The sound quality was fine, the voice acting was acceptable..Nothing really stood out though..

Overall: 4/10
You have potential, but it was too short to even count as a proper movie.

[Review Request Club]

[The Blues]

Pretty dull.

Art/Animation: 5/10
The graphics are pretty shabby. Try using shading and putting in more detail. The animation was also pretty straightforward. However, I liked those music notes on the scale, and the textured BG was also a nice touch.

Plot/Concept: 5/10
It really wasn't that funny, to be honest. Also, what happened to the father? He was there at the start, and we never see him again..Strange family..

Audio/Music: 4/10
A bit of BG music would have been nice. Also, the sound quality was really bad.

Overall: 5/10
Generally pretty boring. Certainly nothing special.

[Review Request Club]

[Castle Crashing The Clay]

Stick to voice acting, I think..

Art/Animation: 2/10
Well, the actual animation was extremely short, so there's very little I can say about it. However, you did manage to keep the lighting consistent, which is not always easy with stop-motion animation.

The text wasn't too good either. It was the world's most boring font (Times New Roman) on a white background. You'll need to try much harder..

Plot/Concept: 1/10
There wasn't really any plot or concept. I'll give you 1 point for the peanut joke :P

Audio/Music: 4/10
The music was fine, but it didn't match the flash at all. You're a voice actor, so you could have actually said the things in text, it would have made it better.

Overall: 2/10
Whatever you do, don't give up the day job :P

[Review Request Club]

ForNoReason responds:

lol, I won't give it up man. Thanks for being honest, and yeah, ill stick with the voice acting. This was more of an experiment than anything. Thanks for your criticism!