Insanimation's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[Change is in the Air]

Nice and relaxing

For what it is, it's really good. The melody is good and constantly changing so I never get bored, but it still sounds like the same song throughout.

For some reason, I was trying to think of what it'd be used in, and what came into my mind was the credits of some cricket show, where it has loads of replays..It has that sort of relaxed feel to it..

[Review Request Club]

Sawdust responds:

Well, repetitivity is a beast I've never managed to slay. Thanks then!

[Game Over Guitar Theme]

Not quite "Game Over"

I agree with Coop, it doesn't really feel like a Game Over, more a menu screen..However, it is still a great song..

I could also see it being used in one of those ads on TV, with amazing HD footage, advertising some new HD Channel or Sony's new 456" HD Ready Plasma TV.

My only criticism is that it doesn't loop perfectly..That would have been nice, as it is a loop after all...

[Review Request Club]

sarias responds:

im not sure how to make it loop any better then it is because on my audio editing software it looped fine but i uploaded it on here and it didn't so im not sure how to fix that

[-rT- WiP : Digital Extacy]

Pity...

I have a slight problem here: I love piano, but hate techno..

The piano intro was quite nice..If I were you, I would have just made it a piano song, as you obviously have a talent for piano. The beat was a bit fast and didn't really go with the piano, but it wasn't too bad..When that techno thump came in I just gave up hope though...I guess it's just not my thing..

The ending just cut it off completely. Try to end it properly.

[Review Request Club]

ReaperTechno responds:

Ive actually redone the piano a little bit since i posted this. It flows through the intro a lot better. If your willing to listen through the techno i might be adding more piano: The only thing i have left to do is determine the direction of this song, theres so much i can do with it.
but thanks for the review :)

[Paradox (Remastered)]

Vocals aren't very good

I loved the V for Vendetta intro, it instantly got me interested, and it's also a great film. However, we are here to review your song, not the film.

The vocals are the main problem here. I'm not really much into this style of singing, but I appreciate it when it is done well. Unfortunately, this is not it.

The music isn't too good either. The beat doesn't work when it's just that constant hitting of the drums, and the guitar doesn't always seem to match the vocals.

I think for this kind of music, a fade out doesn't really work. TRy to find a more precise ending.

[Review Request Club]

Blackdoom13 responds:

Ok thanks for the review. I'll try to do something better for an ending.

[Rondoesque]

Relaxing

The melody was lovely, and very relaxing. I think it worked best when it was going slow, but the faster bits were nice too.

I quite like how it almost loops back to the start seamlessly.

I could see this being an intro to almost any British TV show pre-1990, especially Poirot or something.

There's not much I can about it, but excellent job!

[Review Request Club]

sarias responds:

what tv do you watch? im curious lol i mean really what? thanks for the review though :)

[The Terminator (Revamped)]

Nice intro.

The piano intro was my favourite bit, and a nice contrast from the heavier main part of the song.

You managed to transition into the metal bit flawlessly, so good job on that. The guitars was really nice, and kept me interested throughout. The drum beat was pretty good, but I think there was one cymbal too many..

The ending was a bit lazy, but still worked alright..

[Review Request Club]

Blackdoom13 responds:

Ok thanks for the review.

[Ecliptic]

Not bad..

It kinda sounded like the whole thing was just an intro, or maybe a series or intros, with no proper conclusion.

It was also really repetitive and dull, and had no single melody, but kinda switched between them, so it didn't feel like a full song.

I quite liked the ending though..It fit quite well with the song.

[Review Request Club]

EvilScorpio responds:

Well... At least you've like something in this track)) Thx for the review))

[Galuminum]

Interesting..

The 8-bit beat thing is really kinda annoying..Too much vibrato or something...Not sure about the musical jargon, but it bugged me.

To be honest, this was too much of a Video Game song to be filed under Heavy Metal. I could recognise bits of heavy metal in there, but the instruments were too electronic to be metal..That said, I like how you've tried to combine two very contrasting genres. It creates an original and interesting effect. The metal bits of it are the best parts, in my opinion.

The thing that bugged me the most is that at 1:08, the melody changed completely, and felt like a completely different song...

[Review Request Club]

loansindi responds:

I'm curious exactly what it was that bothered you about the electronic aspects.

Regarding the disjointedness, it's because this is basically two different approaches to the genre that were stuck together. It's still a nascent project.

Thank you for the review.